To judge a loyalty program, measure enrollment rate, active member rate, redemption rate, breakage, repeat purchase rate, the spending gap between members and non-members, retention, churn and overall ROI. When the program runs in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, also watch pass add rate, active passes, pass deletion rate and point-of-sale scan rate. Measure each over a set time window against a baseline.
Measuring sign-ups and participation
Enrollment shows whether people join; engagement shows whether they do anything afterward. Define “active” once (an action within a window) and keep it fixed all year.
Enrollment rate = (new members in the period ÷ eligible customers in the period) × 100
Active member rate = (active members ÷ total members) × 100
According to Bond Brand Loyalty’s 2023 Loyalty Report, the average US consumer holds memberships in 18 programs but actively uses only around half of them (Bond Brand Loyalty, 2023). Well below 50%? Review how members are reminded the program exists.
Tracking redemption and unused rewards
Redemption tells you whether members think rewards are worth chasing. Breakage measures the opposite: value you hand out that nobody ever uses.
Redemption rate = (points or rewards redeemed ÷ points or rewards issued) × 100
Across its ecommerce merchants, Smile.io found an average redemption rate of 13.67% (Smile.io). Epsilon puts the range for healthy enterprise programs at roughly 15% to 35% (Epsilon). When redemption lags, put the point balance where members can see it and show them how far they are from their next reward.
Breakage rate = ((points issued minus points redeemed) ÷ points issued) × 100
High breakage lowers reward costs but signals members drifting away. In Antavo’s 2025 research, 40.7% of consumers said they want points that never expire (Antavo, 2025). To bring breakage down, reduce the threshold for the first reward and remind members ahead of any expiry date.
Measuring member spend and loyalty over time
These metrics show whether the program changes buying behavior and whether members stay.
Spend lift = ((average member spend minus average non-member spend) ÷ average non-member spend) × 100
Bonds measured shoppers who received its wallet offers against shoppers who did not. The exposed group placed 45% more orders, bought 38% more items per order and generated 93% more revenue per customer (Bonds case study). For the bigger picture on keeping customers coming back, read our guide to customer retention strategies with mobile wallets.
Churn rate = (members lost or lapsed in the period ÷ members at the start of the period) × 100
Drawing on the work of Bain & Company’s Frederick Reichheld, Harvard Business Review reports that raising customer retention by 5% can increase profits by 25% to 95% (HBR, 2014). Because no one formally cancels a free program, a lapsed member is the workable definition of a lost one. Organizations that care more about renewals than individual purchases can see how wallet passes support digital memberships.
Calculating cost and return on investment
ROI shows whether the program earns back its full cost.
Program ROI = ((incremental gross margin minus total program cost) ÷ total program cost) × 100
Count everything in total program cost: rewards, technology, setup, staff hours, marketing and any physical card printing. Among program owners in Antavo’s 2025 report who track ROI, 83% said their program delivered a positive return. A simple USD example: a program costing $60,000 per year that generates $150,000 in incremental gross margin returns 150%.
Wallet metrics that standard loyalty guides overlook
When the loyalty card sits in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, the pass becomes the member’s main touchpoint.
Pass add rate = (passes added ÷ unique views of the add-to-wallet button, QR code or link) × 100
LUNE achieved a wallet adoption rate of 87.5% (LUNE case study). For ways to get more customers saving a pass, see our digital loyalty card solutions.
A climbing pass deletion rate is an early churn signal, usually caused by push notifications that are too frequent or not relevant.
Scan rate = (member transactions where a pass was scanned ÷ all member transactions) × 100
Every other metric depends on scan rate. When members skip identifying themselves at checkout, you lose the transaction data and they miss out on points.
Quick reference: loyalty KPIs and what they reveal
| Metric | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Enrollment rate | Whether your sign-up process works |
| Active member rate | How big the program really is |
| Redemption rate | How appealing your rewards are |
| Breakage rate | Disengagement and outstanding liability |
| Spend lift | What a member is worth |
| Retention and churn | Whether members keep coming back |
| Program ROI | Whether the program pays off |
| Pass add rate | How many customers adopt the wallet pass |
| Pass deletion rate | Churn within the wallet |
| Scan rate | How accurate your data is |

How Litecard helps
Litecard builds and manages Apple Wallet and Google Wallet loyalty and membership passes that integrate with your CRM, POS and ecommerce platform. You can send passes through a link, QR code, email, SMS or landing page, which lets you measure adoption by store and by channel. Litecard charges a monthly subscription based on enrolled users, with no fees per pass or per notification. Details are on our pricing page.
Ready to track these metrics for your own program? Book a Litecard demo.
Frequently asked questions
Which KPIs matter most for a loyalty program?
The essential KPIs are enrollment rate, active member rate, redemption rate, breakage rate, spend by members compared with non-members, retention, churn and program ROI. If the program runs in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, add pass add rate, active passes, pass deletion rate and scan rate.
What is the formula for loyalty program ROI?
Subtract total program cost from incremental gross margin, divide the result by total program cost, then multiply by 100. Base incremental margin on a holdout group or a pre-launch baseline, and include rewards, technology, setup, staff time and marketing in the cost figure.
What counts as a good loyalty redemption rate?
No single benchmark applies to every business. Smile.io found an average of 13.67% across its ecommerce merchants, while Epsilon says healthy enterprise programs fall between 15% and 35%. Low redemption usually means members cannot see their balance or feel rewards are out of reach.
How should you measure a mobile wallet loyalty program?
Combine standard loyalty KPIs with wallet-specific metrics: pass add rate, active passes, pass deletion rate, point-of-sale scan rate and the actions members take after a pass notification. Using a unique QR code or link for each store and channel shows which locations drive the most sign-ups.



